收稿日期: 2007-09-11
修回日期: 2008-01-08
网络出版日期: 2008-02-10
基金资助
国家重点基础研究发展计划项目“青藏高原环境变化及其对全球变化的响应与适应对策”（编号:2005CB422006）;中国科学院知识创新工程领域前沿项目“青藏高原冰湖变化及其潜在灾害评价与预警研究”（编号：KZCX2-YW-310）和“应对气候变化影响的国别研究及对策”（编号：KZCX2-YW-305）共同资助.
Progress on the Projections of Future Climate Change with Various Emission Scenarios
Received date: 2007-09-11
Revised date: 2008-01-08
Online published: 2008-02-10
概述未来不同排放情景下气候变化预估研究的主要进展。首先，对用于开展气候变化预估研究的不同复杂程度的气候系统及地球系统模式及其模拟能力进行了简要的介绍，指出虽然目前气候系统模式在很多方面存在着较大的不确定性，但大体说来可提供当前气候状况的可信模拟结果；进而介绍了IPCC不同的排放情景，以及不同排放情景下全球与东亚区域气候变化预估的主要结果。研究表明，尽管不同模式对不同情景下未来气候变化预估的结果存有差异，但对未来50～100年全球气候变化的模拟大体一致，即全球将持续增温、降水出现区域性增加。在此基础上，概述了全球气候模式模拟结果的区域化技术，并重点介绍了降尺度方法的分类与应用。同时对气候变化预估的不确定性进行了讨论。最后，对气候变化预估的研究前景进行了展望，并讨论了未来我国气候变化预估研究的重点发展方向。
张雪芹 , 林朝晖 , 彭莉莉 . 未来不同排放情景下气候变化预估研究进展[J]. 地球科学进展, 2008 , 23(2) : 174 -185 . DOI: 10.11867/j.issn.1001-8166.2008.02.0174
Researches on the projection of climate change are comprehensively reviewed here. Firstly, three kinds of climate models are presented in order to evaluate the ability of models (in particular coupled atmosphere-ocean general circulation models) in the application of climate change projection. It is outlined that coupled models can provide credible simulations of the present climate for most variables of interest for climate change although clouds and humidity remain significant sources of uncertainty. Secondly, a series of emission scenarios released by the IPCC are summarized, so are the results of climate change projections at the global scale and in East Asia. Analysis indicates that in spite of the different outputs from global climate models (GCMs) with various scenarios, the model experiments show similar climate pattern with global warming and the regional increasing of mean precipitation over the 21st century. Considering the coarse spatial resolution of GCMs for many subgrid scales, this paper introduces the downscaling techniques used to enhance the regional details of climate projection. Then, the uncertainties of climate change projection are addressed. At last, the perspectives of research on the future climate change projection as well as the priority focus of climate change projection in China are discussed.
[1] Haeberli W，Beniston M. Climate change and its impacts on glaciers and permafrost in the Alps [J]. Ambio，1998，27（4）: 258-265.
[2] Cramer W，Bondeau A，Woodward F I，et al. Global response of terrestrial ecosystem structure and function to CO2 and climate change: Results from six dynamic global vegetation models [J]. Global Change Biology，2001，7（4）: 357-373.
[3] Parton W J，Scurlock J M O，Ojima D S，et al. Impact of climate change on grassland production and soil carbon worldwide [J]. Global Change Biology，1995，1（1）: 13-22.
[4] National Assessment Report on Climate Change Compiling Committee. National Assessment Report on Climate Change [M]. Beijing: Science Press，2007. [《气候变化国家评估报告》编写委员会. 气候变化国家评估报告[M]. 北京: 科学出版社，2007.]
[5] Lü Xuedu，Wang Wenyuan. Advance and Prospect of Researches on Global-Climate Change [M]. Beijing: China Meteorological Press，2003. [吕学都，王文远. 全球气候变化研究:进展与展望[M]. 北京: 气象出版社，2003.]
[6] IPCC WGⅠ.Climate change 2007: The physical science basis: Summary for policymakers [EB/OL].http://www.ipcc.ch/SPM2feb07.pdf. 2007.
[7] Knutson T R，Delworth T L，Dixon K W，et al. Model assessment of regional surface temperature trends （1949-1997）[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research，1999，104: 30 981-30 996.
[8] Flato G M，Boer G J. Warming asymmetry in climate change simulations [J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2001，28: 195-198.
[9] Colman R A. On the vertical extent of GCM feedbacks [J]. Climate Dynamics，2001，17（5）: 391-405.
[10] Shackley S，Young P，Parkinson S，et al. Uncertainty，complexity and concepts of good science in climate change modeling: Are GCMs the best tools? [J]. Climatic Change，1998，38: 159-205.
[11] Wang Zaizhi，Yu Rucong，Bao Qing，et al. A comparison of the atmospheric circulations simulated by the FGOALS-s and SAMIL [J]. Chinese Journal of Atmospheric Sciences，2007，31（2）: 202-213. [王在志，宇如聪，包庆，等. 大气环流模式（SAMIL）海气耦合前后性能的比较[J]. 大气科学，2007，31（2）: 202-213.]
[12] Houghton J T，Ding Y，Griggs D J，et al. Climate Change 2001: The Scientific Basis [M]. United Kingdom and New York: Cambridge University Press，2001:473，476，536-543，585，617.
[13] Peck S C，Teisberg T J. International CO2 emissions targets and timetables: An analysis of the AOSIS proposal [J]. Environmental Modeling and Assessment，1996，1（4）: 219-227.
[14] Manne A S，Richels R G. The Kyoto protocol: A cost-effective strategy for meeting environmental objectives? [J]. The Energy Journal，1999，Special Issue:1-24.
[15] Nordhaus W D. Managing the Global Commons: The Economics of Climate Change [M]. Cambridge: The MIT Press，1994.
[16] Tol R S J. Spatial and temporal efficiency in climate change: Applications of FUND [J].Environmental and Resource Economics，1999，14（1）: 33-49.
[17] Zeng Qingcun，Zhang Xuehong，Liang Xingzhong，et al. Documentation of IAP two-level atmospheric general circulation model [R]. DOE/ER/60314-H1，TR044，1989:383.
[18] Zhang Xuehong，Liang Xingzhong. A numerical world ocean general circulation model [J]. Advances in Atmospheric Sciences，1989，6: 43-61.
[19] Zhang Xuehong，Bao Ning，Yu Rucong，et al. Coupling scheme experiments based on an atmospheric and an oceanic GCM [J]. Chinese Journal of Atmospheric Sciences，1992，16: 129-144.
[20] Liu Hui，Jin Xiangze，Zhang Xuehong，et al. A coupling experiment of an atmosphere and an ocean model with a monthly anomaly exchange scheme [J]. Advances in Atmospheric Sciences，1996，13: 133-146.
[21] Houghton J T，Jenkins G J，Ephraums J J，et al. Climate Change 1990: The Scientific Basis [M]. UK，Cambridge: Cambridge University Press，1990.
[22] Houghton J T，Meira Filho L G，Bruce J，et al. Climate Change 1994: Radiative Forcing of Climate Change and an Evaluation of the IPCC IS92 Emission Scenarios [M]. UK: Cambridge University Press，1994.
[23] Gates W L，Boyle J S，Covey C，et al. An overview of the results of the Atmospheric Model Intercomparison Project（AMIP）[J]. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society，1999，80（1）: 29-55.
[24] Taylor K E. Summarizing multiple aspects of model performance in a single diagram [J]. Journal of Geophysical Research，2001，106（D7）: 7 183-7 192.
[25] Henderson-Sellers A，Pitman A J，Love P K，et al. The project for intercomparison of land surface parameterization schemes（PILPS）: Phases 2 and 3 [J]. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society，1995，76（4）: 489-503.
[26] Covey C，Abe-Ouchi A，Boer G J，et al. The seasonal cycle in coupled ocean-atmosphere general circulation models [J]. Climate Dynamics，2000a，16: 775-787.
[27] Covey C，AchutaRao K M，Lambert S J，et al. Intercomparison of present and future climates simulated by coupled ocean-atmosphere GCMs [R].PCMDL Report No 66，program for climate model diagnosis and intercomparison，Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory，University of California，Livermore，CA，2000.
[28] Yin Chonghua，Yan Xiaodong，Shi Zhengguo. Progress of the study on Earth system models of intermediate complexity in recent years [J]. Advances in Earth Science，2007，22（3）: 70-76.[尹崇华，延晓冬，石正国. 近年来中等复杂程度地球系统模式的研究进展[J]. 地球科学进展，2007，22（3）: 70-76.]
[29] Nakicenovic N，Alcamo J，Davis G，et al. IPCC Special Report on Emission Scenarios [M]. UK， Cambridge : Cambridge University Press，2001: 4-5.
[30] Watson R T，Albritton D L，Barker T，et al. Climate Change 2001: Synthesis Report [M]. UK: Cambridge University Press，2001: 203-204.
[31] IPCC WGⅢ. Further work of the IPCC on emission scenarios [EB/OL].http://www. ipcc. ch/meet/Lscmntyanex 2 decsn 18 sept 06. pdf，2006.
[32] Stouffer R J，Manabe S. Response of a coupled ocean-atmosphere model to increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide: Sensitivity to the rate of increase [J]. Journal of Climate，1999，12（8）: 2 224-2 237.
[33] Washington W M，Weatherly J W，Meehl G A，et al. Parallel climate model（PCM） control and transient simulations [J]. Climate Dynamics，2000，16: 755-774.
[34] Cox P M，Betts R A，Jones C D，et al. Acceleration of global warming due to carbon-cycle feedbacks in a coupled climate model [J]. Nature，2000，408: 184-187.
[35] Meehl G A，Boer G J，Covey C，et al. The coupled model intercomparison project（CMIP）[J]. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society，2000，81: 313-318.
[36] Wang Huijun，Zeng Qingcun，Zhang Xuehong. Simulation of climate change due to double CO2 [J]. Science in China（Series B），1992，（6）:663-672.[王会军，曾庆存，张学洪. 大气中CO2含量加倍引起的气候变化的数值模拟研究[J]. 中国科学:B辑，1992，（6）:663-672.]
[37] Guo Yufu，Yu Yongqiang，Liu Xiying，et al. Simulation of climate change induced by CO2 increasing for East Asia with IAP/LASG GOALS model [J]. Advances in Atmospheric Sciences，2001，18:53-66.
[38] Stendel M，Schmith T，Roeckner E. The climate of the 21st century: Transient simulations with a coupled atmosphere-ocean general circulation model [R]. Danmarks Klimacenter Report 00-6，Danish Meteorological Institute，Copenhagen，Denmark，2000，51.
[39] Roeckner E，Bengtsson L，Feichter J，et al. Transient climate changes simulations with a coupled atmosphere-ocean GCM including the tropospheric sulfur cycle [J]. Journal of Climate，1998，12（10）: 3 004-3 032.
[40] Gregory J M，Stott P A，Cresswell D J，et al. Recent and future changes in Arctic sea ice simulated by the HadCM3 AOGCM [J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2002，29（24）: 28.1-28.4.
[41] Boville B A，Kiehl J T，Rasch P J，et al. Improvements to the NCAR-CSM-1 for transient climate simulations [J]. Journal of Climate，2001，14: 164-179.
[42] Xu Ying，Zhao Zongci，Luo Yong，et al. Climate change projections for the 21st century by the NCC/IAP T63 model with SRES scenarios [J]. Acta Meteorologica Sinica，2005，19（4）: 407-417.
[43] Ding Yihui，Xu Ying，Zhao Zongci，et al. Climate change scenarios over East Asia and China in the future 100 years [J]. Newsletter on Climate Change，2003/2004，2004，1: 2-4.
[44] Xu Ying. Numerical simulation research on the impact of human activities on climate change [D]. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Meteorological Sciences，2002.[徐影.人类活动对气候变化影响的数值模拟研究[D]. 北京: 中国气象科学研究院，2002.]
[45] Zhao Zongci，Li Xiaodong. Impacts of global warming on climate change over East Asia as simulated by 15 GCMs [J]. World Resources Review，1997，10: 17-21.
[46] Zhao Zongci，Gao Xuejie，Tang Maocang. Environmental characteristics of western China and their change [C]∥Qing Dahe，ed. Assessment on Environment of Western China（Vol.2）. Beijing: Science Press，2002:10-40.[赵宗慈，高学杰，汤懋苍.气候变化预测，中国西部地区的环境演变[C]∥秦大河总主编.中国西北环境特征及其演变（第二卷）.北京: 科学出版社， 2002:10-40.]
[47] Xu Yinlong，Xue Feng，Lin Yihua. Changes of surface air temperature and precipitation in China during the 21st century simulated by HadCM2 under different greenhouse gas emission scenarios [J]. Climatic and Environmental Research，2003，8（2）: 209-217.[许吟隆，薛峰，林一骅.不同温室气体排放情景下中国21世纪地面气温和降水变化的模拟分析[J]. 气候与环境研究，2003，8（2）: 209-217.]
[48] Jiang Dabang，Wang Huijun，Lang Xianmei. Multimodel ensemble prediction for climate change trend of China under SRES A2 scenario [J]. Chinese Journal of Geophysics，2004，47（5）: 776-784. [姜大膀，王会军，郎咸梅. SRES A2情景下中国气候未来变化的多模式集合预测结果[J]. 地球物理学报，2004，47（5）: 776-784.]
[49] Qin Dahe，Ding Yihui，Su Jilan，et al. Climate and Environment Change in China（Vol.Ⅰ）: Climate and Environment Evolution [M]. Beijing: Science Press，2005:513.[秦大河，丁一汇，苏纪兰，等. 中国气候与环境演变（上卷）: 气候与环境的演变及预测[M]. 北京: 科学出版社，2005:513.]
[50] Wilby R L，Wigley T M L. Downscaling general circulation model output: A review of methods and limitations [J]. Progress in Physical Geography，1997，21（4）: 530-548.
[51] Xu Ying，Ding Yihui，Zhao Zongci，et al. Prediction of climate change in middle and lower reaches of the Yangtze River in the 21st century [J]. Journal of Natural Disasters，2004，13（1）: 25-31.[徐影，丁一汇，赵宗慈，等.长江中下游地区21世纪气候变化情景预测[J]. 自然灾害学报，2004，13（1）: 25-31.]
[52] von Storch H. Inconsistencies at the interface between climate research and climate impact studies [J]. Meteorologische Zeitschrift（Stuttgart），1995，4: 72-80.
[53] Giorgi F，Mearns L O. Approaches to the simulation of regional climate change—A review [J]. Reviews of Geophysics，1991，29: 191-216.
[54] Whetton P H，Katzfey J J，Hennesey K J，et al. Using regional climate models to develop fine resolution scenarios of climate change: An example for Victoria，Australia [J]. Climate Research，2001，16: 181-201.
[55] Giorgi F，Mearns L O，Shields S，et al. Regional nested model simulations of present day and 2 CO2 Climate over the Central Plains of the United States [J]. Climatic Change，1998，40: 457-493.
[56] Kato H，Nishizawa K，Hirakuchi H，et al. Performance of the RegCM2.5/NCAR-CSM nested system for the simulation of climate change in East Asia caused by global warming [J]. Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan，2001，79（1）: 99-121.
[57] Chen Ming，Fu Congbin. A nest procedure between regional and global climate model and its application in long term climate simulations [J]. Chinese Journal of Atmospheric Sciences，2000，24（2）: 253-263. [陈明，符淙斌. 区域和全球模式的嵌套技术及其长期积分试验[J]. 大气科学，2000，24（2）: 253-263.]
[58] Gao Xuejie，Zhao Zongci，Ding Yihui，et al. Climate change due to greenhouse effects in China as simulated by a regional climate model [J]. Advances in Atmospheric Sciences，2001，18（6）:1 224-1 230.
[59] Ju Lixia，Wang Huijun. Modern climate over East Asia simulated by a regional climate model nested in a global gridpoint general circulation model [J]. Chinese Journal of Geophysics，2006， 49（1）: 52-60.[鞠丽霞，王会军. 用全球大气环流模式嵌套区域气候模式模拟东亚现代气候[J]. 地球物理学报，2006，49（1）: 52-60.]
[60] Shi Guangyu，Wang Xihong，Zhang Lisheng，et al. Impact of human activities on climate: Impact on climate variability over East Asia and China [J]. Climatic and Environmental Research，2002，7:255-266.[石广玉，王喜红，张立盛，等. 人类活动对气候变化的影响: 对东亚和中国气候变率的影响[J]. 气候与环境研究，2002，7: 255-266.]
[61] Xu Yinlong，Zhang Yong，Lin Yihua，et al. Simulated climate change impact on China under SRES B2 scenario with PRECIS [J]. Chinese Science Bulletin，2006，51（17）: 2 068-2 074.[许吟隆，张勇，林一骅，等.利用PRECIS分析SRES B2情景下中国区域的气候变化响应[J]. 科学通报，2006，51（17）: 2 068-2 074.]
[62] Xiong Wei，Xu Yinlong，Lin Erda，et al. Regional simulation of rice yield change under two emission scenarios of greenhouse gases [J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology，2005，16（1）: 65-68. [熊伟，许吟隆，林而达，等.两种温室气体排放方案下我国水稻产量变化模拟[J]. 应用生态学报，2005，16（1）: 65-68.]
[63] Fu Congbin，Wang Shuyu，Xiong Zhe. Progress report on regional climate model intercomparison project for Asia [J]. Climatic and Environmental Research，2004，9（2）: 225-239. [符淙斌，王淑瑜，熊[XCZ.TIF]. 亚洲区域气候模式比较计划的进展[J]. 气候与环境研究，2004，9（2）: 225-239.]
[64] Fan Lijun，Fu Congbin，Chen Deliang. Review on creating future climate change scenarios by statistical downscaling techniques [J]. Advances in Earth Science，2005，20（3）:320-329.[范丽军，符淙斌，陈德亮. 统计降尺度对未来区域气候变化情景估计的研究进展 [J]. 地球科学进展，2005，20（3）:320-329.]
[65] Zorita E，von Storch H. The analog method as a simple statistical downscaling technique comparison with more complicated methods [J]. Journal of Climate，1995，12（8）: 2 474-2 489.
[66] Winkler J A，Palutikof J P，Andresen J A，et al. the simulation of daily temperature time series from GCM output. Part: Sensitivity analysis of an empirical transfer function methodology [J]. Journal of Climate，1997，10: 2 514-2 535.
[67] Chen D L，Chen Y. Association between winter temperature in China and upper air circulation over East Asia revealed by Canonical Correlation Analysis [J]. Global and Planetary Change，2003，37: 315-325.
[68] Chen D L，Hellstrom C. The influence of the North Atlantic Oscillation on the regional temperature variability in Sweden: Spatial and temporal variations [J]. Tellus，1999，51A（4）: 505-516.
[69] Kalnay E，Kanamitsu M，Kistler R，et al. The NCEP/NCAR 40-Year Reanalysis Project [J]. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society，1996，77: 437-471.
[70] Fan Lijun. Statistical downscaling of local and regional climate scenarios over china [D]. Beijing: The Institute of Atmospheric Physics，Chinese Academy of Science，2006. [范丽军. 统计降尺度方法的研究及其对中国未来区域气候情景的预估[D]. 北京:中国科学院大气物理研究所，2006.]
[71] Benestad R E. Empirically downscaled multi-model ensemble temperature and precipitation scenarios for Norway [J]. Journal of Climate，2002，15: 3 008-3 027.
[72] Benestad R E. Empirically downscaled temperature scenarios for northern Europe based on a multi-model ensemble [J]. Climate Research，2002，21（2）:105-125.
[73] Wilks D S，Wilby R L. The weather generation game: A review of stochastic weather models [J]. Progress in Physical Geography，1999，23: 329-357.
[74] Liao Yaoming，Zhang Qiang，Chen Deliang. Precipitation simulation in China with a weather generator [J]. Acta Geographica Sinica，2004，14（4）: 417-426.[廖要明，张强，陈德亮. 中国天气发生器的降水模拟[J]. 地理学报，2004，14（4）: 417-426.]
[75] Xiong Wei，Tao Fulu，Xu Yinlong，et al. Simulation of rice yield under climatic change in future in China [J]. Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology，2001，22（3）: 1-5. [熊伟，陶福禄，许吟隆，等.气候变化情景下我国水稻产量变化模拟[J]. 中国农业气象，2001，22（3）: 1-5.]
[76] Busuioc A，von Storch H. Changes in the winter precipitation in Romania and its relation to the large scale circulation [J]. Tellus，1999，48A: 538-552.
[77] Kass E，Li T S，Schmith T. Statistical hindcast of wind climatology in the North Atlantic and Northwestern European region [J]. Climate Research，1996，7: 97-110.
[78] Zorita E，Laine A. Dependence of salinity and oxygen concentrations in the Baltic Sea on the large-scale atmospheric circulation [J]. Climate Research，1999，14: 25-34.
[79] Webster M D，Babiker M，Mayer M，et al. Uncertainty in emissions projections for climate models [J]. Atmospheric Environment，2002，36（22）: 3 659-3 670.
[80] Knutti R，Stocker T F，Joos F，et al. Constraints on radiative forcing and future climate change from observations and climate model ensembles [J]. Nature，2002，416: 719-723.
[81] Stott P A，Kettleborough J A. Origins and estimates of uncertainty in predictions of twenty-first century temperature rise [J]. Nature，2002，416: 723-726.
[82] Murphy J M，Sexton D M H，Barnett D N，et al. Quantification of modelling uncertainties in a large ensemble of climate change simulations [J]. Nature，2004，430:768-772.
[83] Jones R N，Hennessy K J，Page C M，et al. An analysis of the effects of the Kyoto Protocol on Pacific Island Countries，Part 2: regional climate change scenarios and risk assessment methods [R]. CSIRO Atmospheric Research Report to the South Pacific Regional Environment Programme，CSIRO，1999.
[84] Lal M，Giorgi F. Regional Climate Modelling and Applications [R]. The World Climate Research Programme: Achievements，benefits and challenges，Geneva，Switzerland，WMO，1997.
[85] Palmer T N，Shutts G J，Hagedorn R，et al. Representing model uncertainty in weather and climate prediction [J]. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences，2005，33: 163-193.
[86] Palmer T N，Alessandri A，Andersen U，et al. Development of a European multimodel ensemble system for seasonal-to-interannual prediction（DEMETER）[J]. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society，2004，85: 853-872.
[87] Hagedorn R，Doblas-Reyes F J，Palmer T N. The rationale behind the success of multi-model ensembles in seasonal forecasting. Part I: Basic concept [J]. Tellus A，2005，57: 219-233.
[88] Lambert S J，Boer G J. CMIP1 evaluation and intercomparison of coupled climate models [J]. Climate Dynamics，2001 17: 83-106.
[89] Zhao Zongci. Latest advances in global climate projections [J]. Advances in Climate Change Research，2006，2（2）: 68-70. [赵宗慈. 全球气候变化预估最新研究进展[J]. 气候变化研究进展，2006，2（2）: 68-70.]
[90] Zhou Tianjun，Yu Yongqiang，Yu Rucong，et al. Coupled climate system model coupler review [J]. Chinese Journal of Atmospheric Sciences，2004，28（6）: 993-1 008. [周天军，俞永强，宇如聪，等.气候系统模式发展中的耦合器研制问题[J]. 大气科学，2004，28（6）: 993-1 008.]
[91] Killeen T，DeLuca C，Gombosi T，et al. Integrated Frameworks for Earth and Space Weather Simulation. Preprint presented at the American Meteorological Society Meeting，Atlanta，GA [EB/OL]. http://ams.confex.com/ams/pdfpapers/105593.pdf. 2006.
[92] Price A，Lenton T，Cox S，et al. GENIE: Grid enabled integrated Earth system model [J]. ERCIM News，2005，61:15-16.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |
甘公网安备62010202000687
