地球科学进展 ›› 2005, Vol. 20 ›› Issue (10): 1059 -1066. doi: 10.11867/j.issn.1001-8166.2005.10.1059

学术论文 上一篇    下一篇

新经济地理学与传统经济地理学之比较研究
刘安国 1,杨开忠 2,谢燮 3   
  1. 1.北京化工大学经济管理学院,北京 100029;2.北京大学政府管理学院,北京 100871;3.交通部水运科学研究所,北京 100088
  • 收稿日期:2005-04-06 修回日期:2005-07-12 出版日期:2005-10-25
  • 通讯作者: 杨开忠(1962-),男,湖南常德人,教授,博士生导师,主要从事区域经济、区域政策和旅游开发与规划研究. E-mail:ykz@pku.edu.cn
  • 基金资助:

    北京化工大学青年教师自然科学研究基金项目“开放条件下的产业空间积聚机理研究”(编号:QN0317);国家自然科学基金项目“我国区域城镇化管理的系统研究”(编号:70433002)资助.

A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NEW ECONOMIC GEOGRAPHY AND TRADITIONAL ECONOMIC GEOGRAPHY

LIU An-guo 1; YANG Kaizhong 2;XIE Xie 3   

  1. 1.School of Economics and Management, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029,China;
    2.School of Government Administration, Peking University, Beijing 100871,China;
    3.Waterborne Transportation Institute, Beijing 100088,China
  • Received:2005-04-06 Revised:2005-07-12 Online:2005-10-25 Published:2005-10-25

自20世纪90年代以来,藤田、克鲁格曼、维纳布斯等以迪克西特和斯蒂格利茨垄断竞争模型为基础,用不完全竞争、报酬递增和市场外部性等理念构建新的经济地理模型,掀起了一场“新经济地理学”革命。新经济地理学在理论基础、研究特点和方法等方面与传统经济地理学表现出明显不同,其理论创新受到经济学界和地理学界的普遍关注。但是,也有一些学者对它提出了同样引人注目的抨击。通过对新经济地理学与传统经济地理学进行比较,对一些重大理论假设、研究方法与特点进行简要分析,有助于廓清对新经济地理学与传统经济地理学之异同的正确认识,以期推动新经济地理学的理论研究与应用以及新经济地理学与传统经济地理学领域的学术交流。

From 1990s onwards, Fujita, Krugman and Venables et al.use conceptual tools of imperfect competition, increasing returns and pecuniary externality to construct theoretical models of new economic geography on the basis of Dixit-Stiglitz framework of monopolistic competition, which leads to a revolution of new economic geography. In terms of theoretical roots and research method, new economic geography exhibits noticeable difference from traditional economic geography. Its theoretical innovation attracts attention from academic circles of both economics and geography. However, new economic geography has been under severe criticism even since its emergence. While some criticism makes academic sense, unfortunately, owing to a lack of full understanding of the theoretical rationale of new economic geography, other criticism actually misses the point. This paper aims to making a comparative study of new economic geography and traditional economic geography in terms of theoretical assumptions, research methods and their respective features. It is hoped that the discussion here will contribute to a clear understanding of the differences as well as similarities between new economic geography and traditional economic geography, which may forward the further research in and application of new economic geography as well as communication between circles of new economic geography and traditional economic geography.

中图分类号: 

[1] Fujita Masahisa. A monopolistic competition model of spatial agglomeration: A differentiated products approach [J]. Regional Science and Urban Economics, 1988,18: 87-124.
[2] Krugman Paul. Increasing returns and economic geography [J]. Journal of Political Economy,1991, 99: 483-499.
[3] Venables A J. Equilibrium locations of vertically linked industries [J]. International Economic Review, 1996, 37: 341-359.
[4] Puga D. The rise and fall of regional inequalities [J]. European Economic Review, 1998, 43: 303-334.
[5] Dixit A K, Stiglitz J E. Monopolistic competition and optimum product diversity [J].American Economic Review, 1977, 67: 297-308.
[6] Fujita M, Krugman P,Venables A. The Spatial Economy: Cities, Regions, and International Trade [M]. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1999. 
[7] Li Xiaojian, Li Qingchun. A review of paul Krugmen’s economic geography [J]. Progress in Geography,1999, 18(2):97-102. [李小建,李庆春. 克鲁格曼的主要经济地理学观点分析 [J].地理科学进展,1999, 18(2):97-102.]
[8] Zhang Fayu. Content of and comments on new economic geography [J]. Economics Information,2000, (11): 72-76. [张发余. 新经济地理学的研究内容及其评价[J].经济学动态, 2000, (11): 72-76.]
[9] Liu Anguo, Yang Kaizhong. Comments on theory and models of new economic geography [J]. Economics Information,2001,(12):67-72. [刘安国,杨开忠. 新经济地理学理论与模型评介[J].经济学动态, 2001,(12):67-72.]
[10] Xie Xie, Yang Kaizhong. The theoretical base of new economic geography [J]. Modern Economic Science,2004, 26(4):53-57. [谢燮, 杨开忠. 新经济地理学诞生的理论基石[J].当代经济科学, 2004, 26(4):53-57.]
[11] Guo Liping, Shen Yufang. Progress in and comments on new economic geography [J]. Academic Research,2003,(7):73-76. [郭利平, 沈玉芳. 新经济地理学的进展与评价[J].学术研究, 2003,(7):73-76.]
[12] Zhang Wenzhong. Study angles of the new econom in geography [J]. Progress in Geography,2003, 22(1):94-97. [张文忠. 新经济地理学的研究视角探析[J].地理科学进展, 2003, 22(1):94-97.]
[13] He Wei. A review of literature in new economic geography [J]. Economics Information,2004,(7):100-104. [何伟. 新经济地理学研究文献综述[J].经济学动态, 2004,(7):100-104.]
[14] Yang Haiyu, Wang Yaozhong, Liu Zhizhong. Comments on center-periphery model of new economic geography [J]. Economics Information,2004,(7):109-113. [杨海余,王耀中,刘志忠.新经济地理学的中心—外围模型评介[J]. 经济学动态, 2004,(7):109-113.]
[15] Liu Anguo. China’s Accession into WTO and the Eevolution of its Spatial Economy[D]. Beijing: Peking University, 2002. [刘安国. 加入WTO和中国经济格局演化[D]. 北京:北京大学, 2002.]
[16] Peng Zhaohui. Trade Cost, Migration Cost, Human Capital Accumulation and Regional Disparity: A Spatial Equilibrium Model [D]. Beijing: Peking University, 2003. [彭朝晖. 基于人力资本形成的区域经济差异模型[D]. 北京:北京大学, 2003.]
[17] Xie Xie. A Spatial Equilibrium Model under the Incompletion of Labor Mobility: A “New Economic Geography” Extending Frame[D]. Beijing: Peking University, 2003. [谢燮. 人口有限流动的区域差异模型——新经济地理学拓展框架[D]. 北京:北京大学, 2003.]
[18] Zhang Jipeng. New economic geography and industrial Agglomeration in China: With comments on Yang Baoliang’s external economy and industrial agglomeration [J]. World Economic Forum, 2004,(3):65-77. [张吉鹏.新经济地理学与中国产业地理集聚——兼评杨宝良的《外部经济与产业地理集聚》[J].世界经济文汇, 2004,(3):65-77.]
[19] Wang Yaozhong, Liu Zhizhong. Dilemma in and the way out for western China’s introduction of foreign capital: An NEG explanation [J]. Economic Review, 2004,(4):60-68. [王耀中, 刘志忠. 西部引进外资的困境与出路——一个新经济地理学的解析[J]. 经济评论, 2004,(4):60-68.]
[20] Zhu Huayou, Ding Sibao, Gao Bin. The new economic geography and the modification to the paradigm of economic geography [J]. Areal Research and Development, 2003, 22(6):1-5. [朱华友, 丁四保, 高斌. 新经济地理学及其对经济地理学范式的修正[J]. 地域研究与开发,2003, 22(6):1-5.]
[21] Liu Anguo, Yang Kaizhong. A path-dependent model of investment and employment flow in a large economy in a progress of Integration [J].Chinese Geographical Science, 2004,14(4):289-295.
[22] Shi Zubao. Western researchers’ reflection on new economic Geography [J].Economics Information,2004,(7):105-108. [石祖葆. 西方学者关于新经济地理学的若干反思[J].经济学动态,2004,(7):105-108.]
[23] Gu Chaolin, Shi Aihua, Wang Enru. “New Economic Geography”or“Geographical Economics”—A new allied trend of geography and economics [J].Scientia Geographica Sinica,2002, 22(2): 129-135. [顾朝林 ,石爱华,王恩儒. “新经济地理学”与“地理经济学”——兼论西方经济学与地理学融合的新趋向[J].地理科学,2002, 22(2): 129-135.]
[24] Gu Chaolin, Wang Enru, Shi Aihua. Divarication and opposability between“New Economic Geography”and economic geography [J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2002, 57(4): 497-504. [顾朝林,王恩儒,石爱华.“新经济地理学”与经济地理学的分异与对立[J].地理学报, 2002, 57(4): 497-504.] 
[25] Smith A. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations [M]. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1976.
[26] Young Allyn. Increasing returns and economic progress[J].The Economic Journal,1928, 38: 527-542.
[27] Puga D. European regional policy in light of recent location theories [J].Journal of Economic Geography,2002,2(4):372-406.
[28] Marshall A. Principles of Economics  (8th ed)[M]. London: Macmillan,1920.
[29] Yang Xiaokai. Principles of Economics [M]. Beijing: Chinese Social Science Press, 1998.286. [杨小凯. 经济学原理[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社, 1998.286.]
[30] Krugman Paul. Development, Geography, and Economic Theory [M]. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1995.17.
[31] Ottaviano G, Puga D. Agglomeration in the global economy: A survey of the new economic geography [J].World Economy,1998, 21: 715. 
[32] von Thunen J H. von Thunen's Isolated State [M].Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1966.
[33] Christaller W. Central Places in Southern Germany [M]. Jena, Germany: Fischer.1933 (English translation by C. W. Baskin, London: Prentice Hall, 1966).
[34] Losch A. The Economics of Location[M]. Jena, Germany: Fischer,1940 (English translation, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1954).
[35] Beckmann M, Thisse J F. The location of production activities[A]. In:Nijkamp P, ed. Handbook of Regional Economics [C]. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1986.21-95.
[36] Alonso W. Location and Land Use [M]. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1964.
[37] Zipf G. Human Behavior and the Principle of Least Effort [M]. New York: Addison-Wesley, 1949.
[38] Mills E S. An aggregative model of resource allocation in a metropolitan area [J].American Economic Review,1967, 57: 197-210.
[39] Henderson J V. Urban Development: Theory, Fact, and Illusion [M]. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988.
[40] Harris C. The market as a factor in the localization of industry in the United States [A]. In:Annals of the Association of American Geographers[C].1954, 64: 315-348.
[41] Pred A. The Spatial Dynamics of U. S. Urban-Industrial Growth [M]. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1966.
[42] Puga D, Venables A J. The Spread of Industry: Spatial Agglomeration In Economic Development[Z].Discussion Paper No. 279, Center for Economic Performance, London School of Economics,1996.3-4.
[43] Scitovsky Tibor. Two concepts of external economy [J].Journal of Political Economy,1954,62: 143-151.
[44] Krugman P. Geography and Trade [M]. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1993.115.
[45] Arthur  B. Positive Feedback in the Economy [A].In: Increasing Returns and Path Dependence in the Economy [C]. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1994.
[46] Puga  D. European Regional Policy in Light of Recent Location Theories[Z].University of Toronto and CEPR, Revised draft, Nov,1998.
[47] Davis D, Weinstein D. Economic Geography and Regional Production Structure: An Empirical Investigation[Z].NBER Working Paper 6093, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA 02138, 1996.
[48] Henderson V. Externalities and Industrial Development [Z]. NBER Working Paper 4730, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA 02138, 1996.
[49] Hanson G. Economic integration, intraindustry trade, and frontier regions[J].European Economic Review,1996, 40: 941-949.
[50] Hanson G. Increasing Returns, Trade, and the Regional Structure of Wages[M]. Mimeograph, University of Texas, Austin,1996. 
[51] Hanson G. Localization economies, vertical organization, and trade[J]. American Economic Review, 1996, 86 (5): 1 266-1 278.

[1] 赵燕慧, 路紫. 航线网络碳排放模型及外部性要素分析[J]. 地球科学进展, 2018, 33(1): 103-111.
阅读次数
全文


摘要